Time to jettison outdated welfare system and start afresh
Posted on November 2, 2012 in Social Security Policy Context
Source: Toronto Star — Authors: Carol Goar
TheStar.com – opinion/editorialopinion
November 01, 2012. By Carol Goar, Editorial Board
It took Frances Lankin and Munir Sheikh two years to untangle the 800 rules, 240 benefit rates, add-ons, updates and patch-ups that have turned Ontario’s welfare system into an incomprehensible mess.
It took the Ontario government 15 years — and three premiers — to turn a once-compassionate income support into an $8.3-billion dead weight.
It took provincial bureaucrats countless person-hours to draft and implement the onslaught of regulations, penalties and procedures that have stripped caseworkers of their humanity and stigmatized their clients.
Surely Ontario’s political leaders can find more than a few minutes to address the forward-looking plan proposed by two of the most progressive pragmatists in the country. But not one of them has risen to the challenge.
Premier Dalton McGuinty, who commissioned the report, has said nothing.
Neither Conservative Leader Tim Hudak nor New Democratic Party Leader Andrea Horwath has made any substantive comment.
Social Services Minister John Milloy has undertaken to “consult our partners — both inside and outside of government — to discuss the implications of system transformation and begin creating a responsible road map.” (That’s what the commissioners just did.)
The media, sensing the mood at Queen’s Park, gave the 132-page report a cursory look and declared it well intentioned, but too ambitious for a deficit-burdened, politically unstable province.
That’s one way of looking at it. There is another way.
Ontario has a rare chance to replace an oppressive, needlessly complex social assistance program with a simpler, fairer system.
Social assistance has become the default program for Ontarians with mental disorders, single parents who can’t afford child care, victims of domestic violence, high-school dropouts, inmates who’ve served their time and kids who think crime is the only way out of poverty. It provides them with a subsistence-level income and little hope of anything better. No amount of tinkering will change that.
What Lankin, a former CEO of United Way Toronto, and Sheikh, former chief statistician of Canada, propose is a 10-year plan to replace the province’s overloaded, barnacle-encrusted safety net with a program designed to get people the right kind of help — mental health and addiction services, affordable housing, accessible child care, post-prison reintegration programs and practical employment training — to become as self-sufficient as they can. Many social assistance recipients are employable and want to work. All can live purposeful lives.
The two social assistance commissioners may not have every detail right. But their road map leads in the right direction.
The obstacles are not insurmountable. The provincial deficit is shrinking faster than anticipated. The economy is still growing, albeit modestly. Ontario’s short-term political outlook is uncertain, but not paralyzing.
The price — starting at $340 million a year and dropping as people leave social assistance — is not prohibitive. It is the equivalent of one day’s worth of provincial government spending.
The public is not dead set against welfare reform — just anxious and disengaged.
The principal thing holding Ontario back is an absence of political courage.
Suppose McGuinty had welcomed the report with enthusiasm and made it a personal priority to persuade his Liberal colleagues to incorporate it into their leadership platforms and the party’s next election platform.
Suppose Horwath, whose party once stood up for the poor, had embraced the work of fellow New Democrat Frances Lankin and made it part of her vision for Ontario.
Suppose someone in the Conservative caucus had dared say to Hudak: “This makes economic sense. Denigrating the poor is yesterday’s politics.”
Suppose one of the bankers or business leaders who endorsed Brighter Prospects
had gone a step further and publicly urged the province’s political leaders to wake up and recognize that Ontario needs the skills and abilities of all its citizens to cope with the demographic challenges it faces.
Opinion polls will never say it’s safe to take a political risk. Circumstances will never be ideal. The timing will never be right.
So here is the choice: Tinker perennially or discard the accumulated baggage and start afresh.
< http://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorialopinion/article/1281330–time-to-jettison-outdated-welfare-system-and-start-afresh-goar >
Tags: budget, featured, Health, homelessness, ideology, mental Health, poverty, standard of living
This entry was posted on Friday, November 2nd, 2012 at 9:34 am and is filed under Social Security Policy Context. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
321 Responses to “Time to jettison outdated welfare system and start afresh”
« Older Comments | Newer Comments »
Recent Comments
Beneficial Blog! I had been simply just debating that there are plenty of screwy results at this issue you now purely replaced my personal belief. Thank you an excellent write-up.
have already been reading ur blog for a couple of days. really enjoy what you posted. btw i will be doing a report about this topic. do you happen to know any great websites or forums that I can find out more? thanks a lot.
I like this weblog very much so much great info .
Beneficial Blog! I had been simply just debating that there are plenty of screwy results at this issue you now purely replaced my personal belief. Thank you an excellent write-up.
These stories are so important.
Public policy is key here, and our states need to develop some strategies – – soon.
When we look at these issues, we know that they are the key ones for our time.
Thanks for a Interesting item; I enjoyed it very much. Regards Sang Magistrale
I had fun reading this post. I want to see more on this subject.. Gives Thanks for writing this nice article.. Anyway, I’m going to subscribe to your rss and I wish you write great articles again soon.
I enjoy your blog posts, saved to my bookmarks!
Does it look like we’re in for a big ride here?
Hi, possibly i’m being a little off topic here, but I was browsing your site and it looks stimulating. I’m writing a blog and trying to make it look neat, but everytime I touch it I mess something up. Did you design the blog yourself?
Simply want to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your post is just great and i can assume you’re an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the gratifying work.
Most often since i look for a blog Document realize that the vast majority of blog pages happen to be amateurish. Not so,We can honestly claim for which you writen is definitely great and then your webpage rock solid.
I am very happy to look your post. Thanks a lot and i am taking a look ahead to touch you.
It’s clear you’re passionate about the issues.
Is it okay to put a portion of this on my weblog if perhaps I post a reference point to this web page?
How come you do not have your website viewable in mobile format? cant see anything in my Droid.
My brother suggested I might like this web site. He was entirely right. This post actually made my day. You can not imagine simply how much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!
I believe this web site has some really wonderful info for everyone : D.