Early days of the NHS
Discussing the economic woes of Britain’s National Health Service in an era of “austerity-inclined politicians,” Konrad Yakabuski notes that all Western health-care systems face problems of sustainability given “the demands of an aging population and the wrath of tapped out taxpayers” (Is Our Health System Destined To Follow A U.S. Trajectory? Feb. 8).
Characterizing these systems as “born in the postwar era of abundance,” Mr. Yakabuski seemingly endorses the view that current society can no longer afford the luxury of universal health care. This argument is not well-grounded on a reading of history.
When the NHS was created in 1948, Britain was in economic crisis. With the country reeling in debt and a balance-of-payments deficit, the Labour government adopted a policy of austerity that lasted well into the 1950s. Wartime controls on the marketplace were extended. A case in point: Bread rationing was introduced after the Second World War, not during it. Viewed solely in economic terms, Britain could not afford the NHS in 1946. That the NHS was created speaks to a conscious decision on the part of government to prioritize health care and social services. Ultimately, what a society can or cannot afford is a policy decision.
Mariel Grant, associate professor, department of history, University of Victoria, Victoria
……………………………….
Whatever drove the creation of the NHS, it was not abundance. Historian Tony Judt in Postwar, his magisterial survey of that era, points out that Britain continued to maintain the illusion of being a great power without the resources to do so. Part of its resources went to paying the huge war debt to the United States, part to military expenditures. One result was that food rationing in Britain went on till 1954 – long after it had ended in the rest of Western Europe.
The creation of the NHS was a courageous decision by the Labour Party to radically improve the lives of British people. It benefited most sectors of society – hence the continuing broad support for it. Mr. Judt comments on the timing of the NHS’s introduction: “Precisely because times were difficult, the postwar welfare systems were a guarantee of a certain minimum or justice, or fairness.” We should be grateful that politicians once thought like that.
Christopher Petty, Winnipeg
……………………………….
As a seven year old in 1948 postwar Britain, I remember workers wearing surplus army clothing, food rationing and shortages of everything including coal. I suspect the same conditions existed in other European countries.
I do not remember the abundance until 1952 when my family emigrated to Canada, which incidentally did not have a publicly funded national health care system at the time.
David Ankrett, Port Perry, Ont.
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/letters/feb-12-universal-health-cares-humble-origins-plus-other-letters-to-the-editor/article37926745/
Recent Comments
552776 25476Yeah bookmaking this wasnt a speculative decision outstanding post! . 983848
44393 546255A extremely exciting go through, I may not agree completely, but you do make some actually legitimate factors. 920464
734639 963593As soon as I discovered this internet web site I went on reddit to share some of the love with them. 504183
211495 48593An interesting discussion is price comment. I think which you must write extra on this subject, it may well not be a taboo subject but usually individuals are not enough to speak on such topics. Towards the next. Cheers 535767
953412 619955You ought to consider starting an email list. It would take your website to its potential. 247900
261046 251433Great information a lot of thanks sharing and reaching us your subscriber list. 654752
352701 731654TeenVogue? Searching for fashion advice, celebrity buzz or beauty trends? Uncover it all in Teen Vogue 311751
834853 150442Aw, this was a genuinely good post. In concept I wish to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make an superb article nevertheless what can I say I procrastinate alot and not at all appear to get something done. 333452
191381 931013I adore gathering valuable info, this post has got me even a lot more info! . 526734
986808 47203Hoping to go into business venture world-wide-web Indicates revealing your products or services furthermore companies not only to ladies locally, but nevertheless , to numerous prospective clients in which are online in most cases. e-wallet 909218
575282 195401I adore your wp design, wherever did you download it by way of? 650875
441337 716813Im agitated all these post directories. It certain would be good to have every post directory that instantly accepts articles. 10852
972454 559818Definitely composed content material , thankyou for info . 837534
855184 100314hey there, your web site is amazing. I do thank you for function 263941
193752 170087You created some decent points there. I looked on the internet for that concern and located most individuals will go together with with the site. 313495
982319 428279Hiya. Extremely cool website!! Man .. Beautiful .. Fantastic .. I will bookmark your internet internet site and take the feeds additionallyI am pleased to discover numerous helpful info here within the post. Thank you for sharing 143793
749742 628364I got what you intend, saved to fav, very nice web site . 647894