It’s fair to say at this point that the conservative-led movement to discredit Ottawa’s carbon-pricing regime is in tatters.
Two courts in two different provinces have now ruled that the regime is constitutional. At the same time, the climate-change plans introduced by provincial governments that oppose carbon pricing, as well as by the federal Conservative Party, are being criticized for their lack of effectiveness.
Add the continuing implosion of the Doug Ford government in Ontario – it has tried to boost its flagging popularity with an expensive ad campaign targeting the federal plan – and what was once a putative pan-Canadian resistance to the signature environmental policy of Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is looking like a quixotic political crusade.
It was easy to predict this would happen. The Trudeau government was always confident in its legal power to create legislation imposing carbon pricing on provinces that didn’t meet minimal standards for reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Saskatchewan was the first to challenge Ottawa, and the first to lose. The province’s Court of Appeal ruled in May that the federal regime was valid.
Last Friday, the Ontario Court of Appeal came to the same conclusion, with a twist: The thing Conservative Party Leader Andrew Scheer and Mr. Ford love to call a “tax” is in fact a regulatory fee, the judges ruled.
This is in part because the federal levy is imposed on GHG emitting industries and on the producers and distributors of carbon-based fuels, who pass the costs onto consumers. This is the stated purpose of carbon pricing: As a behaviour-changing mechanism that uses price signals to reduce consumption and spur innovation.
But the Ontario court also said carbon pricing is not a tax because the money collected by Ottawa will be sent back to the provinces, with nearly all of it going to individual taxpayers, and the remainder to schools, hospitals, municipalities and small and medium-sized businesses in the five provinces on which it is or will be imposed.
This is the key fact that Mr. Ford and Mr. Scheer, along with Alberta Premier Jason Kenney and Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe, deliberately obfuscate when they inaccurately damn the federal regime as a “tax grab,” without mentioning that the money collected will be returned to Canadians.
The Ontario court has laid it out in black and white. It stands in jarring contrast to the refusal of Mr. Scheer and his allies to do the same.
The Ontario ruling also makes the case for why a federal regime is necessary. The provinces of Mr. Kenney and Mr. Ford – Alberta and Ontario – produce 60 per cent of Canada’s annual GHG emissions, but it is Atlantic Canada and the territories – which produce a combined 6 per cent – that will most feel the consequences of global warming, in the form of rising seas and the loss of permafrost and ice cover.
“As a practical matter and indeed as a legislative matter, there is nothing these provinces and territories can do to address the emission of GHGs by their geographic neighbours and constitutional partners. Without a collective national response, all they can do is prepare for the worst,” the court said in its ruling.
In other words, carbon pricing is about Ottawa getting the provinces to overlook self-interest and jointly fight a battle that is crucial to the federation, not to mention part of a global fight to limit GHG emissions.
Ottawa is also trying to get the provinces to adopt a mechanism that has proven to be a conservative, efficient and market-friendly way of reducing GHG emissions.
Instead, Saskatchewan is appealing to the Supreme Court and Alberta intends to file its own constitutional challenge to the federal plan.
Meanwhile in Ontario, Mr. Ford says his government will lower GHG levels by encouraging companies to develop green technology – an inefficient and bureaucratic solution that will push costs onto consumers in an opaque fashion, and take money out of their pockets that they won’t get back. It also happens to be pretty much the same plan that Mr. Scheer is proposing.
The Liberal scheme is not perfect. It alone will not make Canada meet its GHG reduction commitments under the Paris Agreement. But it has three things going for it that no conservative leader of any stripe has offered so far: coherence, honesty and a realistic chance of making a difference.
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/opinion/editorials/article-the-real-carbon-tax-is-the-money-provinces-are-spending-on-lawyers/
Recent Comments
You are not right. I am assured. I can prove it. Write to me in PM, we will talk.
You are one talented writer thank you for the post.
I favored your idea there, I tell you blogs are so helpful sometimes like looking into people’s private life’s and work.At times this world has too much information to grasp. Every new comment wonderful in its own right.
Thank you for the auspicious writeup.
I’m so happy to read this. This is the type of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that’s at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this best doc.
What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively useful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to contribute & help other users like its aided me. Great job.
Dude.. I am not much into reading, but somehow I got to read lots of articles on your blog. Its amazing how interesting it is for me to visit you very often. –
I just added your web site to my blogroll, I hope you would look at doing the same.
This article actually helped me with a report I was doing.
These kind of posts are always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content so I happy to find many good point here in the post. writing is simply wonderful! thank you for the post
I think I will become a great follower.Just want to say your post is striking. The clarity in your post is simply striking and i can take for granted you are an expert on this subject.
Thank you for sharing this very good post. Very interesting ideas! (as always, btw)
I just couldnt leave your website before saying that I really enjoyed the useful information you offer to your visitors… Will be back often to check up on new stuff you post!
We’re developing some community services to respond to this, and your blog is helpful.
Are grateful for this blog post, it’s tough to find good information and facts on the internet
Nice blog. Could someone with little experience do it, and add updates without messing it up? Good information on here, very informative.
Just what I needed to know thank you for this.
Spot on with this write-up, I actually assume this website needs far more consideration. I will in all probability be once more to learn rather more, thanks for that info.
Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again soon!
When are you going to post again? You really entertain me!