Long-awaited audit of Ontario children’s aid societies reveals growing deficits and rising safety incidents
Posted on November 17, 2026 in Child & Family Delivery System
Source: TheStar.com — Authors: Megan Ogilvie and Amy Dempsey Raven
TheStar.com – News/Investigation
Nov. 17, 2026. By Megan Ogilvie Health Reporter, and Amy Dempsey Raven Investigative Reporter
The release of the report comes after the Star reported the findings have been in the government’s hands for almost a year.
An audit of Ontario children’s aid societies has not uncovered the “nightmare stories” of agencies misusing taxpayer dollars that Premier Doug Ford vowed to expose when he announced the review two years ago.
Instead, it has found that the cost of caring for children and youth with complex needs has skyrocketed as child welfare agencies — forced to become “providers of last resort” for desperate families — lean on high-cost emergency placements.
The audit says nearly two-thirds of children’s aid societies are in some kind of financial distress and the number of serious safety incidents for kids in care has nearly doubled from 2020 to 2025.
The alarming portrait of the province’s child welfare system is included in the long-awaited report, released Monday as the provincial government announced new legislation and regulatory changes it says will strengthen the sector.
But while the changes tighten financial oversight and impose new safety measures, experts and critics say they do not address the underlying issues that are sending kids with complex health needs to the doorsteps of children’s aid.
“We have a child welfare system that is ill-equipped to deal with the demands presenting themselves,” said Kiaras Gharabaghi, professor at Toronto Metropolitan University’s school of child and youth care, after reviewing the audit’s findings.
“Ontario governments continue to respond to these issues with a mixture of indignation that it costs money to ensure the well-being of children and an absurd confidence that tinkering with technical aspects of the system is somehow going to produce transformative change,” Gharabaghi said. “It will not.”
When asked Monday why the legislation does not address long-standing systemic issues, Michael Parsa, minister of children, community and social services, pointed to the government’s “record funding” in the sector — some $2 billion — even as the number of children and youth in care has decreased by 20 per cent. He said placement decisions are made by societies, not the government.
“We have an expectation to make sure that those placements are safe, so every child and youth in the province is supported, protected, and their outcomes improved,” he said.
Alexa Gilmour, NDP critic for children, community and social services and MPP for Parkdale—High Park, said on Monday that she is “livid” the legislation meant to address the audit findings are “tucked in” to an omnibus bill, along with health-care issues, long-term-care home requirements and sweeping new changes to OSAP.
“There is nothing that really tackles the seriousness of (the issues) these families are facing,” Gilmour said, adding that children who are in crisis now cannot wait months for change.
The release of the report, which examined 37 non-Indigenous societies, comes in the wake of Star reporting that revealed the findings have been in the government’s hands for almost a year — despite repeated promises from the province it would make the results public.
The delay drew sharp criticism from advocates and critics who say the child welfare system has continued to deteriorate in the two years since the premier announced the audit.
Despite raising the alarm since 2020, child welfare agencies are still struggling to find appropriate treatment and housing for kids with complex mental health and other developmental needs. The lack of options has forced agencies to rely on unlicensed settings, including budget motels, and other emergency placements.
The Star recently reported on a teen boy in southwestern Ontario who lived in his family’s shed for months while under the watch of children’s aid.
Previous Star reporting has shown these emergency placements are driving up agency costs and harming vulnerable children and youth.
The audit found the same. Spending across the child welfare sector is heavily concentrated in high-cost, reactive protection ($437 million) and care ($642 million), while prevention and early intervention accounts for only $53 million — under 4 per cent — of spending.
Three quarters of all placement spending went to outside purchased resources, or OPRs, which can include private foster or group care providers that children’s aid societies purchase services from.
The increasing reliance on OPRs stems from a provincewide decline in foster families and the increasing complexity of needs among children in care, the audit said.
The number of serious safety incidents for kids in care nearly doubled over the five years reviewed by auditors, with incidents of exploitation such as sex trafficking increasing by 33 per cent and assaults up 18 per cent. Most of these incidents occurred in OPRs, the audit noted.
Ford ordered the third-party audit of the sector in October 2024, alleging he’d heard “nightmare stories” of agencies misusing taxpayer dollars instead of properly funding care.
At the time, union leaders representing thousands of child protection workers called the audit a “smokescreen” and stated the government needed to adequately fund the social services system to ensure children got the help they need.
The audit was conducted by an outside contractor and looked at the quality of child protection services and examined operational costs, including executive compensation and staffing. The review did not include Indigenous child and family well-being agencies.
While the KPMG audit did not make formal recommendations, noting that it wasn’t in the scope of its contract with the provincial government, it offered “considerations” for future policy and decision-making. Among them, auditors warned that sector-wide structural changes may be needed to address high-cost placements that are out of agencies’ control.
Parsa said the proposed legislation includes new oversight for social workers that would see their licenses suspended or revoked if they are found to have committed sexual misconduct involving a client. That ban would remain in place for a minimum of 10 years.
Megan Ogilvie is a Toronto-based health reporter for the Star. Amy Dempsey Raven is an investigative reporter for the Star, based in Ottawa.
https://www.thestar.com/news/investigations/rising-safety-incidents-growing-deficits-inside-ontario-children-s-aid-societies-long-awaited-report-reveals/article_aaf3158b-d6ab-4922-aad3-d08fac159ada.html
Tags: budget, child care, jurisdiction, youth
This entry was posted on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026 at 11:29 am and is filed under Child & Family Delivery System. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
Recent Comments