Ottawa needs to fix a broken provincial transfer payment System
TheGlobeandMail.com – ROB/Economy/Economy Lab
Dec. 13 2013. Robin Boadway, Serge Coulombe And Jean-François Tremblay
As the country’s finance ministers prepare to meet next week, one big item that was expected to be on the agenda, but will not be, is the future of federal-provincial transfer payments.
Although existing arrangements technically expire in March, 2014, this perennial topic of federal-provincial discord is evidently off the policy radar screen. Indeed, the federal government’s previous unilateral decisions, taken well in advance of the renewal deadline, have successfully pre-empted the debate.
This is unfortunate, as it means that governments are missing a crucial opportunity to strengthen key adjustment mechanisms in our federation – mechanisms that are sorely needed to cope with a boom-bust resource economy and the regionally skewed growth it produces, and that are required to support a well-functioning economic and social union.
The global resource boom of the past decade has clearly been beneficial to Canada, boosting our economic activity and purchasing power. But it has also significantly widened economic disparities between the resource-rich provinces and the rest of the country, and redefined who are the “haves” and the “have-nots.” During the peak of the resource boom in 2002-08, the economies of Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Newfoundland and Labrador all grew at a remarkable nominal rate of 11 per cent a year, on average. Growth in the other regions of the country was much weaker, at only 4 per cent annually.
These large differences in the provinces’ economic growth are largely a function of unalterable geography – the allocation of resource endowments across our vast country. This, however, quickly translates into wide disparities not only in wages, incomes and job prospects among provinces, but also in provincial governments’ abilities to raise revenues and to provide public services.
Our Constitution’s unique allocation of federal-provincial powers further exacerbates such disparities. Because provinces own, manage and tax their natural resources, and raise most of their own revenues, the resulting large differences in fiscal capacities are of great consequence for the federal government, which is constitutionally bound to address fiscal disparities among the provinces.
The equalization program is the primary tool to address these gaps. It transfers federal revenues to provincial governments with below-average fiscal capacities, so they can provide reasonably comparable public services to elsewhere in the country, with similar tax burdens.
However, as we argue in a recent paper published by the Institute for Research on Public Policy, the equalization program is failing to meet its objectives. There are now larger “shocks” to equalize.
Fiscal disparities before equalization increased by about 20 per cent in the past decade. (See graph
.) This is due mainly to the resource boom, and there’s little that can be done on this score. More importantly, however, the effectiveness of the equalization program has diminished, and as a result, disparities after
equalization have increased much more (by 40 per cent). This reflects the fact that, while have-not provinces are equalized up, provinces with above-average revenue-raising capacities are not equalized down.
Provincial fiscal capacities relative to the national average

Luckily, the path to a stronger equalization program is clear. It doesn’t require a Royal Commission or a major re-working of the program’s arcane formula. A simple, effective way to improve the system is to remove the cap on total program payouts recently imposed by the federal government.
This temporary stop-gap measure was applied in 2009, during the global financial crisis, when Ontario became a “have-not” province. In effect, the perfect storm hit, as equalization payouts were expected to grow at a time when the federal cupboards were bare.
But with federal-provincial transfers technically up for renewal in 2014, the economic and fiscal situation for the federal government is much improved. The worst of the economic crisis has passed and with subsequent policy changes – including reduced growth in federal health care transfers to the provinces – Ottawa now has significant fiscal room to manoeuvre. Conversely, the long-term outlook for the provinces is far worse and features rising, not falling, public debt.
The Parliamentary Budget Office estimates that Ottawa could raise spending or lower taxes by about $25-billion annually without increasing federal debt as a share of the economy over the long run. The cap on equalization payments should be removed. This would allow the program to operate as intended, while likely using up less than one-tenth of Ottawa’s long-term fiscal room.
A complementary approach to address these fiscal inequalities would be for the federal government to tie some of its other transfers to overall provincial revenue-raising capacity. This would mean, for example, that because resource-rich have far higher revenues than other provinces due to their resource wealth, Ottawa would lower their per-capita transfers for health and social spending.
Unfortunately, the federal government is moving in the opposite direction – in favour of equal per-capita cash transfers, under the guise of fairness. In fact, a truly fairer approach would be to use these other transfer programs (such as CHT and CST) to offset some of the interprovincial imbalances created by natural resource endowments.
Discussions of transfer programs have faded from view. Nonetheless, they remain an essential and underused tool for the federal government to play its appropriate adjustment and insurance role in the federation. In fact, they may just be the complementary tools needed to muster national support for Ottawa’s push to increase resource development.
Robin Boadway is a professor at Queen’s University. Serge Coulombe and Jean-François Tremblay are professors at the University of Ottawa. They are the authors of the Institute for Research on Public Policy (IRPP) Insight publication “Canadian Prescriptions for Dutch Disease”.
< http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/economy-lab/ottawa-needs-to-fix-a-broken-provincial-transfer-payment-system/article15958426/#dashboard/follows/ >
Tags: budget, economy, jurisdiction, standard of living, tax
This entry was posted on Friday, December 13th, 2013 at 1:03 pm and is filed under Governance Policy Context. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
291 Responses to “Ottawa needs to fix a broken provincial transfer payment System”
« Older Comments | Newer Comments »
Leave a Reply
Recent Comments
I just sent this post to a bunch of my friends as I agree with most of what you’re saying here and the way you’ve presented it is awesome.
Like the way you’ve outlined things. Easy to follow. Not cluttered.
Hi, do have a e-newsletter? In the event you don’t definately should get on that piece…this web site is pure gold!
Regards for helping out, superb info.
I’ve been surfing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It’s pretty worth enough for me. In my view, if all web owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the net will be much more useful than ever before.
I have been surfing online more than three hours today, yet I never found anything that grabbed my interest as much as this piece.
I like meeting utile info, this post has got me even more info!
I appreciate, cause I found just what I was looking for. You’ve ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye -.
That’s some inspirational stuff. Never knew that opinions might be this varied. Thanks for all the enthusiasm to supply such helpful information here.
Pretty impressive article. I just stumbled upon your site and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your opinions. Any way I’ll be coming back and I hope you post again soon.
I enjoy your blog posts, saved to my bookmarks!
Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I’m impressed! Very useful info specifically the last part 🙂 I care for such info much. I was looking for this certain information for a very long time. Thank you and good luck.
What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively useful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to contribute & help other users like its aided me. Great job.
Greetings, have tried to subscribe to this websites rss feed but I am having a bit of a problem. Can anyone kindly tell me what to do?’
You ma’am have a way with words. Thank you very much!
You have some helpful ideas! Maybe I should consider doing this by myself.
Very Interesting Information! Thank You For Thi Information!
Have you always been concerned about these issues?
These are some of the most important issues we’ll face over the next few decades.
This is valuable stuff.In my opinion, if all website owners and bloggers developed their content they way you have, the internet will be a lot more useful than ever before.