Bringing coherence to our fragmented EI system
Posted on January 22, 2011 in Debates
Source: National Post — Authors: Matthew Mendelsohn, Roy Romanow
NationalPost.com – story
Friday, Jan. 21, 2011. Roy Romanow and Matthew Mendelsohn, National Post
What follows is the last in a five-part series of articles about Employment Insurance from researchers affiliated with the Mowat Centre EI Task Force at the School of Public Policy & Governance at the University of Toronto. The Mowat Centre’s EI Task Force Toronto conference and consultations will be held today.
Canada’s Employment Insurance program is beset with many problems. While the program has evolved substantially since its introduction, its modern iteration has been distorted by partisan politics and ad hoc adjustments designed to put out small, often regional, fires. Most experts agree that the system is broken and needs an overhaul.
If the EI system is to regain the faith of workers and businesses, it needs to be simple, principled and transparent. Workers and employers should know their obligations and entitlements and have a clear understanding of the rationale behind them. This isn’t the case today.
The Mowat Centre is leading a nonpartisan effort to re-design the system. The hope is to present a credible, principled alternative that will enable the federal government to modernize EI so that it works for all Canadians, workers and employers alike. In doing so, we are tackling some big questions, listed below.
Why does the EI system treat Canadians differently based on where they live?
The EI system makes benefits easier to access for longer periods in areas with higher levels of unemployment, responding (in principle) to differing levels of need, as defined by the regional unemployment rate.
This is a worthwhile principle, but in practice most experts argue that it doesn’t make sense.
There is actually little evidence that the local unemployment rate is the best predictor of how difficult it is for any individual to find a job. (Some research, for instance, finds that when the unemployment rate is going up it is harder to find a job, regardless of the actual unemployment rate.) There may be a case for treating workers differently in different regions, but the evidence would need to be compelling to deviate from the principle of equal treatment for all for a basic social entitlement.
Who should qualify for benefits?
Few experts would suggest that the rules for qualification reflect the needs of the modern workforce. New entrants to the labour market must work significantly longer in order to qualify for benefits. Workers who collect benefits on a yearly basis suffer no penalty, while workers who have not collected after decades of contribution receive no additional benefit when they find that they need the program. Temporary Foreign Workers pay into the system but rules basically prevent them from ever collecting. Part-time workers and contract workers — even those working long hours–often cannot qualify if they lose a job
Who should have access to job training?
A portion of the contributions that workers and businesses make to EI fund training for some unemployed workers. The federal government has downloaded responsibility for delivering EI-funded training programs to the provinces, but still continues to define eligibility for these programs through EI.
These restrictions on eligibility may no longer make sense. Many unemployed people now fall outside the EI umbrella. Today’s economy may demand that access to training not be defined by EI eligibility rules, which were crafted for an entirely different purpose: income support, not job training.
If training is a broad economic and social priority, it may make sense to fund training out of general government revenues rather than through EI premiums. This could be part of a national human-capital strategy — or a responsibility transferred to provinces enabling them to design and manage their own training programs to meet their local labour market needs..
How can we improve the co-ordination between EI and other income support programs, like Social Assistance, social housing and tax benefits?
Canada’s broken federal-provincial relations victimize the unemployed. A lack of co-ordination between those making decisions about the federal EI program and provincial social assistance programs creates gaps that are unjustifiable from a labour-market-efficiency and social-justice perspective. A coherent system would be run by one order of government. Other countries have one system. Canada has two parallel systems that are barely on speaking terms.
EI is a foundational piece of our social safety net. For it to retain its legitimacy, it has to be principled, transparent and fair. Business, labour and Canadians generally must see their interests reflected in EI reform.
Canadians have to believe that the government is treating them equitably. Right now, none of these things hold. That isn’t just a problem for our social safety net and our productivity — it’s a problem for our democracy as well.
– Roy Romanow is co-chair of the Advisory Committee of the Mowat Centre EI Task Force. Matthew Mendelsohn is the founding director of the Mowat Centre.
< http://www.nationalpost.com/Bringing+coherence+fragmented+system/4141748/story.html >
Tags: economy, standard of living
This entry was posted on Saturday, January 22nd, 2011 at 10:12 am and is filed under Debates. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
3,106 Responses to “Bringing coherence to our fragmented EI system”
« Older Comments | Newer Comments »
Recent Comments
It’s amazing to visit this site and reading the views
of all colleagues regarding this piece of writing, while I am also eager of getting
know-how.
Today, I went to the beach with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed the shell to
her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside
and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back!
LoL I know this is entirely off topic but I had to tell someone!
Do you mind if I quote a couple of your posts as long as I provide credit and sources back to your
site? My blog is in the very same niche as yours and my visitors would really
benefit from a lot of the information you present here.
Please let me know if this okay with you. Thanks a lot!
It’s a shame you don’t have a donate button! I’d without a doubt donate to this outstanding blog!
I suppose for now i’ll settle for book-marking and adding your RSS feed to my Google account.
I look forward to fresh updates and will talk about this site with my Facebook group.
Talk soon!
Been using Betbolt UK since the middle of this year and honestly it’s grown on me. Game library is pretty massive — must be somewhere around 3,500 titles on there. Pragmatic Play and Play’n GO make up the bulk of it, and Big Time Gaming slots mixed in as well. Sweet Bonanza and Book of Dead are obviously the most popular picks, they run smoothly here. One minor gripe — the lobby search could be a bit slicker, you need some patience to find older or specific titles.
The live table game section are powered by Evolution Gaming which basically means you know you’re in safe hands. Crazy Time, Lightning Roulette, Monopoly Live — they’ve got all the big shows. Proper dealers, decent quality and no complaints on mobile either. Usually I drift between the live games and the slot lobby based on what I fancy.
Betbolt UK’s sign-up offer came as a matched deposit up to 200 plus 100 free spins on one of their Pragmatic slots. The wagering requirement is 35x which is about standard for UK sites. There might be promo codes going — have a look at bet bolts before you deposit since the offers get updated pretty regularly. The min deposit for the welcome offer is 20, standard stuff.
Betbolt UK’s sportsbook is solid — EPL markets are well covered and the odds hold up to the main UK bookies. In-play works well most of the time, but occasionally the markets can refresh slowly during busy match times. Not a dealbreaker but I did clock it.
Withdrawals at Betbolt UK have been fine for me. Been going with Neteller and money’s come through in under 24 hours. The usual UK stuff — Visa, Mastercard, Skrill are all supported, plus crypto if that’s your thing. They’re licensed through the MGA which gives it some credibility at least. Live chat is 24/7 and response was fast the time I queried something.
I’ve been on Betbolt UK for a few months now and not gonna lie it’s grown on me. Game library is pretty massive — must be somewhere around 3,500 titles on there. Play’n GO and NetEnt dominate the lobby, with Big Time Gaming slots mixed in as well. Gates of Olympus and Sweet Bonanza are obviously the most popular picks, they load fine on the site. One minor gripe — game filtering could be a bit slicker, takes a bit of digging to locate specific titles.
The live casino section are powered by Evolution Gaming which basically means quality’s solid. Crazy Time and Lightning Roulette — all the Evolution game shows are covered. Real croupiers, proper studios, and no streaming issues I’ve noticed. I mostly split my time between the slots and the live tables depending on my mood.
The welcome offer at Betbolt UK was a 100% match up to ?100 plus 100 free spins on one of their Pragmatic slots. The wagering requirement is 30x which is nothing crazy by UK casino standards. There might be promo codes going — have a look at bettbolt before you deposit since the offers get updated pretty regularly. The min deposit for the welcome offer is ?20, standard stuff.
Betbolt UK’s sportsbook is decent enough — Premier League coverage are extensive and they compare well against the bigger books. In-play works well generally, but occasionally the markets can refresh slowly during busy match times. Not a dealbreaker but worth noting.
Betbolt UK cashouts have been solid for me. Using a Visa debit and funds arrived in under 24 hours. The usual UK stuff — Visa, Mastercard, Skrill are all there, and there’s Bitcoin if that’s your thing. The site holds an MGA licence so there’s at least some regulatory oversight. Live chat is 24/7 and they were quick when I had a question about a withdrawal.
I’ve been on Betbolt UK since early this year and tbh it’s grown on me. Game library is pretty massive — reckon there’s somewhere around 3,000 games in total. Pragmatic Play and Play’n GO make up the bulk of it, and Big Time Gaming in there too. Gates of Olympus and Sweet Bonanza are obviously the most popular picks, they load fine on the site. The one thing that bugged me — the lobby search isn’t the most intuitive, takes a bit of digging to locate specific titles.
Live dealer games are powered by Evolution Gaming which basically means you know you’re in safe hands. Crazy Time, Lightning Roulette, Monopoly Live — all the Evolution game shows are covered. Proper dealers, decent quality and no complaints on mobile either. I mostly split my time between the slots and the live tables depending on what I fancy.
Betbolt UK’s sign-up offer was a 100% match up to ?200 with 50 free spins on one of their Pragmatic slots. The wagering requirement is 30x which is nothing crazy by UK casino standards. There might be promo codes going — check bet bolt before you deposit since promos get updated pretty regularly. Minimum deposit to get the bonus is ?20, which is fine.
Football betting at Betbolt UK is solid — Premier League coverage are extensive and they compare well to the main UK bookies. Live betting runs smoothly most of the time, but occasionally the markets can refresh slowly on busy matchdays. Minor stuff really but I did clock it.
Betbolt UK cashouts have been solid on my end. Been going with Neteller and funds arrived within a day. Visa, Mastercard, Skrill and Neteller are all supported, and there’s Bitcoin for those who want it. MGA-licensed which gives it some credibility at least. Support runs round the clock via live chat and they were quick the time I queried something.
I’ve been on Betbolt UK for a few months now and honestly it’s turned out better than I expected. The slots section is quite wide — reckon there’s somewhere around 3,000 games in total. Play’n GO and NetEnt make up the bulk of it, and Big Time Gaming in there too. Sweet Bonanza and Book of Dead are obviously the most talked-about titles, they run smoothly here. The one thing that bugged me — game filtering could be a bit slicker, you need some digging to locate specific titles.
The live casino section are powered by Evolution Gaming which basically means quality’s solid. Crazy Time and Lightning Roulette — all the Evolution game shows are covered. Real croupiers, proper studios, and I’ve not had any lag issues. Usually I drift between the slots and the live tables depending on what I fancy.
The welcome offer at Betbolt UK was a 100% match up to ?100 with 100 bonus spins for a Pragmatic Play title. Wagering sits at 35x that’s about standard for UK sites. Have a look at betbolts before you sign up as offers come and go all the time. The min deposit for the welcome offer is ?10, which is fine.
Football betting at Betbolt UK is solid — EPL markets are extensive and they compare well against the bigger books. Live betting runs smoothly generally, though I’ve noticed the markets can refresh slowly during busy match times. Minor stuff really but I did clock it.
Betbolt UK cashouts have been solid on my end. Using a Visa debit and money’s come through within a day. The usual UK stuff — Visa, Mastercard, Skrill are all supported, and there’s Bitcoin if that’s your thing. They’re licensed through the MGA so there’s at least some regulatory oversight. Support runs round the clock via live chat and response was fast the time I queried something.
Been using Betbolt UK since the middle of this year and not gonna lie it’s turned out better than I expected. The slots section is quite wide — reckon there’s upwards of 3,000 games in total. Pragmatic Play and Play’n GO make up the bulk of it, and Big Time Gaming in there too. Sweet Bonanza and Book of Dead are obviously the most talked-about titles, they load fine here. The one thing that bugged me — the lobby search isn’t the most intuitive, you need some digging to locate specific titles.
The live casino section run through Evolution so you know you’re in safe hands. Crazy Time, Lightning Roulette, Monopoly Live — all the Evolution game shows are covered. Proper dealers, decent quality and no complaints on mobile either. Usually I drift between the slots and the live tables based on my mood.
The welcome offer at Betbolt UK was a 100% match up to ?200 with 50 free spins on one of their Pragmatic slots. The wagering requirement is 35x that’s about standard for UK sites. Have a look at betbolts before you register as offers shift around fairly often. Minimum deposit to get the bonus is ?10, which is fine.
Football betting on Betbolt UK is decent enough — Premier League coverage are extensive and they compare well against the bigger books. In-play works well most of the time, though I’ve noticed the odds can lag a bit during busy match times. Not a dealbreaker but worth noting.
Betbolt UK cashouts have been solid on my end. Been going with Neteller and money’s come through in under 24 hours. The usual UK stuff — Visa, Mastercard, Skrill are all supported, and there’s Bitcoin if that’s your thing. They’re licensed through the MGA which gives it some credibility at least. Support runs round the clock via live chat and response was fast when I had a question about a withdrawal.
Hi to every body, it’s my first pay a visit of this blog; this website includes remarkable and in fact good data for visitors.
I’ve been on Betbolt UK for a few months now and honestly it’s turned out better than I expected. The slots section is pretty massive — reckon there’s somewhere around 3,500 games in total. Pragmatic Play and Play’n GO dominate the lobby, and Big Time Gaming slots mixed in as well. Gates of Olympus and Sweet Bonanza are obviously the most talked-about titles, they load fine here. One minor gripe — game filtering could be a bit slicker, takes a bit of digging to locate specific titles.
Live dealer games run through Evolution so quality’s solid. Crazy Time and Lightning Roulette — all the Evolution game shows are covered. Proper dealers, decent quality and no complaints on mobile either. I mostly split my time between the live games and the slot lobby based on my mood.
Betbolt UK’s sign-up offer was a 100% match up to ?100 plus 100 bonus spins for a Pragmatic Play title. The wagering requirement is 35x which is nothing crazy by UK casino standards. There might be promo codes going — check bet bolts before you deposit since promos get updated pretty regularly. The min deposit for the welcome offer is ?20, standard stuff.
Betbolt UK’s sportsbook is solid — Premier League coverage are well covered and they hold up against the bigger books. Live betting runs smoothly most of the time, though I’ve noticed the markets can refresh slowly during busy match times. Not a dealbreaker but worth noting.
Withdrawals at Betbolt UK have been fine on my end. Been going with Neteller and funds arrived in under 24 hours. Visa, Mastercard, Skrill and Neteller are all there, and there’s Bitcoin if that’s your thing. MGA-licensed which gives it some credibility at least. Support runs round the clock via live chat and they were quick when I had a question about a withdrawal.
Been using Betbolt UK since the middle of this year and not gonna lie it’s grown on me. The slots section is pretty massive — reckon there’s upwards of 3,000 games in total. Pragmatic Play and Play’n GO dominate the lobby, with Big Time Gaming in there too. Sweet Bonanza and Book of Dead are obviously the most popular picks, they load fine on the site. The one thing that bugged me — game filtering isn’t the most intuitive, you need some patience to find older or specific titles.
Live dealer games are powered by Evolution Gaming which basically means you know you’re in safe hands. Crazy Time, Lightning Roulette, Monopoly Live — the main game shows are all there. Real croupiers, proper studios, and I’ve not had any lag issues. Usually I drift between the slots and the live tables depending on my mood.
The welcome bonus at Betbolt UK came as a matched deposit up to ?200 plus 50 bonus spins for a Pragmatic Play title. Wagering sits at 35x which is nothing crazy by UK casino standards. There might be promo codes going — check betbolt before you deposit since the offers get updated pretty regularly. Minimum deposit to get the bonus is ?20, which is fine.
Betbolt UK’s sportsbook is decent enough — Premier League coverage are extensive and the odds hold up to the main UK bookies. In-play works well generally, but occasionally the markets can refresh slowly during busy match times. Not a dealbreaker but I did clock it.
Withdrawals at Betbolt UK have been fine on my end. I use Skrill and money’s come through in under 24 hours. Visa, Mastercard, Skrill and Neteller are all there, and there’s Bitcoin if that’s your thing. The site holds an MGA licence so there’s at least some regulatory oversight. Live chat is 24/7 and response was fast the time I queried something.
Hurrah, that’s what I was exploring for, what a material!
present here at this web site, thanks admin of this site.
Good site you have here.. It’s hard to find
good quality writing like yours nowadays.
I honestly appreciate people like you! Take care!!
Hello there! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you
if that would be okay. I’m undoubtedly enjoying your blog and
look forward to new updates.
What’s up, this weekend is good in favor of me, because this moment i am reading this impressive informative article here at my home.
Hi, of course this post is actually good and I have learned lot of things from it regarding blogging.
thanks.
I really like what you guys tend to be up too. Such clever work and exposure!
Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve you guys to blogroll.
Excellent pieces. Keep writing such kind of info on your blog.
Im really impressed by it.
Hey there, You’ve performed an incredible job. I’ll definitely digg it and for my part recommend to my
friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.
I’ve been on Betbolt UK for a few months now and honestly it’s turned out better than I expected. The slots section is pretty massive — reckon there’s somewhere around 3,500 games in total. Pragmatic Play and Play’n GO dominate the lobby, with Big Time Gaming slots mixed in as well. Gates of Olympus and Sweet Bonanza are still the talked-about titles, they run smoothly on the site. One minor gripe — the lobby search isn’t the most intuitive, takes a bit of patience to find specific titles.
The live table game section run through Evolution which basically means you know you’re in safe hands. Crazy Time and Lightning Roulette — they’ve got all the big shows. Proper dealers, decent quality and no complaints on mobile either. Usually I drift between the live games and the slot lobby depending on my mood.
The welcome offer at Betbolt UK came as a matched deposit up to ?100 plus 50 bonus spins for one of their Pragmatic slots. Wagering sits at 35x that’s nothing crazy by UK casino standards. There might be promo codes going — have a look at betbolt before signing up since the offers change fairly often. Minimum deposit to get the bonus is ?20, standard stuff.
Betbolt UK’s sportsbook is solid — Premier League coverage are extensive and they hold up against the bigger books. Live betting runs smoothly generally, though I’ve noticed the odds can lag a bit during busy match times. Not a dealbreaker but worth noting.
Withdrawals at Betbolt UK have been fine for me. I use Skrill and money’s come through in under 24 hours. The usual UK stuff — Visa, Mastercard, Skrill are all there, and there’s Bitcoin for those who want it. MGA-licensed so there’s at least some regulatory oversight. Live chat is 24/7 and they were quick when I had a question about a withdrawal.