The sky-high cost of taxes
Posted on March 18, 2011 in Governance Policy Context
Source: National Post — Authors: William Watson
NationalPost.com – FinancialPost.com/FPComment – Higher corporate tax rates produce less revenue
Mar 17, 2011. William Watson
This page hardly ever recommends violence as a means to better economic policy, but if a special forces team were to kidnap the country’s finance ministers, lock them up in a mountain hideaway and not let them out again until they proved by written or oral examination that they understood the message of a new C.D. Howe Institute study on the economic costs of current Canadian levels of taxation, the country would be a lot better off.
Perhaps you read Profs. Bev Dahlby and Ergete Ferede’s summary of their study here Thursday. One problem with academics is that they sometimes hide even astonishing results under bushel baskets of dispassionate, unassuming prose. Let me say what their modesty wouldn’t allow them to: Prof. Dahlby is one of the world’s leading experts on the economic costs of taxation. He has a 2008 book on the subject from the MIT Press, which is top of the pops for economics. And his and Prof. Ferede’s findings are nothing short of stunning.
You remember the Laffer curve. Two rates of taxation are guaranteed to produce no revenue: zero and 100%. At some rate in between, revenues peak and then start declining. Now you may think governments generally need more revenues or your political philosophy may say they should get by on less. But nobody wants to get onto the wrong side of the Laffer curve, for if you do, any further increase in tax rates actually reduces tax revenues. It’s one of the few situations in economics where there really is a free lunch: You cut tax rates, which makes you everyone’s friend, and you get more tax revenue as a result.
Guess what? Dahlby and Ferede’s work on the responsiveness of provincial tax revenues to provincial tax rates shows that in 2006, the last year their study covers, four Canadian provinces, including the province that accounts for 40% of the country’s population and even more of its economy, were operating their corporate tax systems on the wrong side of the Laffer curve. Besides Ontario, the other guilty parties — “bonehead provinces” would be an equally apt term — were Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia and P.E.I. If they had reduced corporate tax rates, they would have made more corporate tax revenue.
It gets better — or worse, depending how you look at it. Even in those provinces that weren’t on the wrong side of the Laffer curve, the cost of raising an extra dollar of tax revenue using corporate taxes was ridiculously high. In Alberta, it was $40.83. In Newfoundland and Labrador, $30.31. In British Columbia, $11.64. In Manitoba, where the cost of corporate tax was lowest at the margin, it was still $2.25.
With a cost of funds at that level, good cost-benefit analysis would make you judge proposed public expenditure in a very severe light. If you were going to spend $1 of corporate tax revenue on a project, you’d have to insist that the project pay off $2.25 per dollar spent, for that’s what the $1 cost you.
The payoff needn’t be cash, of course. The returns to public spending sometimes, maybe often, come in kind. But if you’re making your decisions in a reasonable way, you’ll want the beneficiaries of the program to be benefiting by $2.25 for every dollar you spend on them. And in the other provinces mentioned, you’d want them to be benefiting by $11.64 (B.C.) or $30.31 (N.L.) or $40.83 (Alberta) per dollar. No doubt many good things are done through Alberta’s public sector, including funding Professors Dahlby and Ferede’s universities (Alberta and Grant MacEwan, respectively). But how many of these good things do you suppose are worth $40.83 per dollar spent?
In Quebec, the cost of a dollar of corporate taxes is “only” $2.57. That’s the good news. The bad news is that the marginal cost of personal income taxes is $3.85. The province last month pledged $200-million toward the cost of a new arena for Quebec City. Maybe that money will come from income taxes, maybe not. But if it does, do you suppose the benefits the province will get out of the arena will amount to $770-million? It’s hard to believe they will.
Quebec has the highest-cost personal income taxes at the margin. But nobody gets off easy. In Ontario they’re $2.16 per dollar of income raised. Do most new public projects in Ontario pay back more than double what’s spent on them? In B.C., the cost is $1.83 per dollar of revenue raised. New Premier Christy Clark seems to be an enthusiast for public initiatives. How many will pay off at $1.83 per buck invested?
What accounts for these costs? Where do they come from? Taxes cause people to change their behaviour. Tax an activity and people will do it less or, in the case of corporations, they’ll do it somewhere else. They were doing whatever it is you decided to tax because it provided benefits. If the tax kills the activity, the benefits evaporate.
Some of our tax rates are pretty high. Push them a little higher and you lose a lot of beneficial activity. (There’s also, of course, the extra administrative cost of levying and policing the tax, but Dahlby and Ferede don’t even consider that. In that sense, their estimates are underestimates.)
If you’re not already depressed enough, consider this: The federal government subsidizes all this inefficiency by compensating the provinces for the loss in tax capacity that their own fool taxes bring about. Even when the marginal economic cost of a tax is sky-high, provinces may not actually suffer very much, at least revenue-wise, as a result. Equalization bails them out.
I suppose on reflection that kidnapping our finance ministers may not be the best way to get them to absorb the lessons of this crucially important study. But at the very least they should have Dahlby and Ferede’s estimates of the marginal cost of public funds inscribed in neon on their office doors so they’re reminded of it every day they go to work.
< http://opinion.financialpost.com/2011/03/17/william-watson-the-sky-high-cost-of-taxes/ >
< http://financialpostopinion.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/fe0318-cost-of-dollar-eps.jpg >
This entry was posted on Friday, March 18th, 2011 at 10:43 am and is filed under Governance Policy Context. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
267 Responses to “The sky-high cost of taxes”
« Older Comments | Newer Comments »

Recent Comments
Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I’ve really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again soon!
I think this is among the so much vital info for me. And i’m happy reading your article. But wanna remark on few common issues, The site style is wonderful, the articles is really excellent : D. Just right job, cheers
These kind of posts are always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content so I happy to find many good point here in the post. writing is simply wonderful! thank you for the post
Developing a framework is important.
Have you given any kind of thought at all with converting your current web-site into French? I know a couple of of translaters here that will would certainly help you do it for no cost if you want to get in touch with me personally.
I was suggested this website by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as no one else know such detailed about my difficulty. You are wonderful! Thanks!
There is perceptibly a lot to identify about this. I consider you made some good points in features also.
Fantastic piece of writing here1
Some truly nice stuff on this website , I like it.
Nevertheless, it’s all carried out with tongues rooted solidly in cheeks, and everybody has got nothing but absolutely love for their friendly neighborhood scapegoat. In reality, he is not merely a pushover. He is simply that extraordinary breed of person solid enough to take all that good natured ribbing for what it really is.
Some truly interesting info , well written and broadly user genial .
Your idea is outstanding; the issue is something that not enough persons are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy that I stumbled throughout this in my seek for one thing regarding this.
Thanks For This Blog, was added to my bookmarks.
I am glad to be a visitor of this thoroughgoing web blog ! , regards for this rare information! .
Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained I’m sure you had fun writing this article.
Assume you are doing good linking to position you on the first pages of search engines.
My issues have been very similar, with my family. But, we made some different decisions. It’s complex.
Nice post.Very useful info specifically the last part 🙂 Thank you and good luck.
It’s continually awesome when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I’m sure you had fun writing this article. Regards, Clotilde.
The start of a fast-growing trend?