Targeted child care misses mark

Posted on January 4, 2008 in Child & Family Debates, Inclusion Debates

—

TheStar.com – comment
January 04, 2008
CAROL GOAR

Intuitively, it makes sense that early learning programs should be targeted at low-income children. They face bigger hurdles than other youngsters. They’re more likely to struggle at school. They have a higher risk of dropping out and perpetuating the poverty cycle.

Yet pediatricians, teachers and psychologists consistently advocate that all pre-schoolers be treated equally.

For the past 15 years, Canada’s politicians have ignored the experts and gone with their guts.

The result is a patchwork of programs aimed at youngsters living in poor neighbourhoods, aboriginal communities and single-parent households.

It fails on two counts, says Gillian Doherty who has just completed a comprehensive review of Canada’s children’s policies. First, it isn’t particularly cost-effective. Second, it excludes 70 per cent of youngsters with development problems.

“Targeting misses the mark most of the time,” she says. “We’re just not getting to the kids who need help.”

Doherty, a child development psychologist, has spent 30 years as an educator, provincial policy-maker and researcher. She has just completed a study for the Institute for Research on Public Policy (www.irpp.org) that pulls together the lessons she has learned:

The first is that most developmentally delayed children come from middle-income and affluent families. The incidence may be higher among economically disadvantaged kids, but numerically, the vast majority of vulnerable children are neither poor nor distinguishable from their peers.

“Many people are unaware of this,” Doherty says. “The problem is much bigger than people realize and it cuts across income groups.”

The second is that programs designed to change the behaviour of low-income parents – to improve their child-rearing skills or get them into the workforce – have little impact on their offspring.

“These interventions may benefit parents,” Doherty says, “but they generally have negligible effects on children’s development.”

The third is that vulnerable kids do best in structured, full-day programs. Less formal types of care reduce their odds of succeeding at school and becoming healthy, self-supporting adults.

“Poor quality child care is not simply a missed developmental opportunity, it is known to be detrimental to all children’s development,” Doherty says. “Canada cannot continue to treat this service as simply a safe place for children to stay while their parents work.”

Her final overarching conclusion is that universal programs are a better investment of public funds than initiatives targeted at kids that “everybody knows will have difficulty.”

This proposition is also the most controversial, Doherty admits. Taxpayers don’t like being told that their preconceptions are wrong, especially when the status quo is cheaper than change.

“But Canada cannot afford the inevitable negative consequences to its prosperity of failing to implement a universal system,” she says.

She is pleased that Ontario finally appears to be heeding the research.

Premier Dalton McGuinty announced in November that his government would phase in a universal, full-day kindergarten program starting in 2010. Once that is in place, the province can begin extending it to younger children, working toward an early childhood education system that is open and affordable to all families.

Such an undertaking would be expensive, the author concedes. By her estimate, it would cost about $5.6 billion to put in place a high-quality, universal early childhood education system in Ontario ($15 billion nationwide).

But within a generation, the payback – in reduced dropout rates, lower welfare expenditures, increased employment income and higher tax revenues – would outweigh the costs two to one, Doherty says.

She doubts that Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who sees no role for Ottawa in early childhood development, will be receptive to this message. Nor is she expecting widespread support in the business community.

But she hopes middle- and upper-income voters – who have the power to decide elections – take a hard look at the evidence.

Targeted preschool programs aren’t serving Canada’s children well. Politicians aren’t qualified to pick the kids who need help. Allowing millions of children to fall short of their potential, with labour shortages looming, is bad economic planning.

Gut instincts can be powerful. But they’re not the basis for sound public policy.

online pharmacy buspar for sale no prescription
online pharmacy buy prograf online no prescription
buy zovirax online zovirax no prescription

This entry was posted on Friday, January 4th, 2008 at 1:00 am and is filed under Child & Family Debates, Inclusion Debates. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

38 Responses to “Targeted child care misses mark”

  1. Meditate early, finish the story, then clean up in free roam. PSN and Xbox lists mirror each other outside the platinum. 25f12a69.

  2. Subscription sharing means your existing WoW sub already covers it. A Hardcore ruleset is planned for winter 2026 per the roadmap. bae5db5c.

  3. This protocol breakdown addresses several vital clinical aspects regarding dosage safety, contraindications, and sustained efficacy over extended regimens. Very helpful reference!

  4. A remarkably comprehensive overview of clinical utility and proper administration protocols. The emphasis on quality assurance and verified sourcing standards is well-timed.

  5. Players can review the setup steps before starting their first session. 0a964ff2.

  6. This website truuly has aall of thee infoo I needed concerning thi subject aand didn’t know who to ask.
    xnxx

  7. The game has a Warcraft look while keeping a survivors-style loop. 5115d99f.

  8. Simply want tto say your article is as astonishing. The clarity on yur submit is
    just excellent and that i can assume you are an exdpert onn
    this subject. Fine along with your permission allow me to snatch your feed to keep updated wigh approaching post.
    Thanks 1,000,000 and lease carrdy on the rewaarding work.

    xnxx

  9. vidstube.cc says:

    Just desire to say your article is as astonishing.

    The clearness in your submit is just nice and i could assume you are knowledgeable on this subject.
    Fine with your permission let me to grasp your feed to stay up to date with approaching post.
    Thank you a million and please keep up the rewarding work.
    xnxx

  10. Hmm it appears like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly
    enjoying your blog. I too am an aspiring blog writer but
    I’m still new to everything. Do you have any recommendations for novice blog writers?
    I’d certainly appreciate it. xnxx

  11. Solid post. There’s so much conflicting advice out there, so it’s refreshing to read something clear. Thanks for putting this together.

  12. dentitoxpro says:

    Great read. I’ve been reading more about natural ways to support my health, and I found this insightful. Great stuff, thank you.

  13. Phytomemone says:

    Great read. It’s easy to neglect our health with busy schedules, so I appreciate these kinds of tips. Really useful, cheers.

  14. sight care says:

    Solid post. Taking care of your health from the inside out makes such a difference over time. Really useful, cheers.

  15. Thanks for sharing this. Health really is everything, and this gave me a few things to think about. Bookmarked for later.

  16. Tinnoril says:

    Thanks for sharing this. A more natural approach to health and wellness has made a real difference for me. Really useful, cheers.

  17. trimology says:

    Solid post. There’s so much conflicting advice out there, so it’s refreshing to read something clear. Bookmarked for later.

  18. Mindoxa says:

    Really enjoyed this. I’ve been focusing on my overall wellness this year, and this fits right in. Looking forward to more like this.

« Older Comments |

Leave a Reply