Specialty medical clinics must be part of new health-care system
TheStar.com – opinion/editorialopinion
December 08, 2012. Francesca Grosso
In 2013 Ontario will have a new premier, possibly a new government. Ontarians should hope that Health Minister Deb Matthews’ commitment to moving certain procedures out of hospitals and into specialized clinics survives the transition. This will achieve three important goals that any government aspires to in health care: greater quality, better access and lower cost.
Clinics have come under attack since a report revealed nine of the 251 facilities providing colonoscopies, cosmetic surgery and cataracts failed quality inspections. We don’t know how hospitals would have done had they been subjected to the same quality inspection because they are not. Obviously, these results are unacceptable.
I have worked for hospitals, not-for-profit and private clinics. All charge OHIP, not patients, for insured services. Quality can be present or absent in each of these settings.
In reporting about these failed clinics, the suggestion is that procedures performed in clinics — moreover, private clinics — are more likely to lack quality than if performed in hospitals, even though they’re done by the same physicians. The arguments confuse in-hospital and out-of-hospital alternatives with the old debate of not-for-profit versus private care.
Vested interests are using this story to advance their own agendas. The Ontario Council of Hospital Unions, which commented on the story, disapproves of moving services out of hospitals. It is hard for bargaining agents to unionize in specialized clinics.
The status quo is where this advocacy ultimately leads.
Let’s consider five key points:
• Hospitals are not necessarily safe places. The landmark Baker-Norton Study in 2004 found that there were 9,250 to 23,750 preventable deaths in Canadian hospitals each year. According to the Canadian Institute of Health Information, some — though not all — hospitals have reduced this number by up to 40 per cent. This means up to 14,000 people die unnecessarily in Canadian hospitals each year, the equivalent of 45 jumbo jets crashing annually.
The Public Health Agency of Canada reports that hospital-acquired infections have risen significantly over the past five years. People who are otherwise healthy are put at greater risk in a hospital setting. If you don’t have to be in a hospital, you shouldn’t want to be.
• There is a link between quality and volume. There is no clear link between quality and ownership. Whether a clinic is not-for-profit likeKensington Health Centre or private like Shouldice Hospital doesn’t determine whether you’ll get better care. Both institutions have provided cost-effective, excellent, insured care.
International research proves that one of the most important determinants of quality is volume. Practice does make perfect. “How many of these procedures do you do?” is a more relevant question than “are you privately owned or not?” In the U.K., the National Health Service outsourced a number of insured procedures like hips and knees to specialty clinics (privately owned, for those who care). Quality studies clearly indicate that these specialty hospitals are outperforming NHS hospitals on quality and patient satisfaction on the same procedures. And costs are lower.
• Appropriate care in the appropriate setting means that hospitals should only be doing the tough stuff. We need all these settings to do what they should be doing. Hospitals are expensive places for care. They require high staffing levels and infrastructures to be able to handle almost anything. They should not be performing certain standard procedures on uncomplicated patients. These can and should be done elsewhere. Hospital advocates charge that clinics “cherry pick” the easy cases and leave hospitals with the most difficult ones. Good — that’s the idea. This will free up resources for people who really need hospital care.
• Specialized clinics will improve access. Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall commented, “If my constituents had to choose between timeless ideology or timely health care, they would pick timely health care.”
Specialty clinics have reduced wait times for cataract surgery and cancer screening in the case of colonoscopies. We need greater access to these services. During my time working with the Ontario PC government, publicly insured but privately delivered MRIs were made available outside of hospitals. The McGuinty government converted these clinics to not-for-profits. Private or not, the result was the same: better access, lower cost.
• Specialized clinics provide cost savings. Specialty clinics perform high volumes of few procedures, which lead to greater standardization and efficiency. Real costs are far more easily identified in less complex settings where few procedure types are performed, enabling government greater control over how much it will pay for the service.
Obviously not everything can or should be done in a specialty clinic and not everybody is a candidate to have a procedure in this environment. It will require better, evidence-based quality oversight. Failure to provide quality must have severe consequences. The same type of scrutiny and consequence should also apply to hospitals.
Arguments for the status quo continue to be a barrier to the public interest — a better, safer, more cost-effective health-care system.
Francesca Grosso is a principal at Grosso McCarthy and a former policy director for the minister of health and long-term care. She is co-author ofNavigating Canada’s Health Care.
< http://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorialopinion/article/1299574–specialty-medical-clinics-must-be-part-of-new-health-care-system >
Tags: budget, Health, ideology, standard of living
This entry was posted on Tuesday, December 11th, 2012 at 10:27 am and is filed under Health Delivery System. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
328 Responses to “Specialty medical clinics must be part of new health-care system”
« Older Comments | Newer Comments »
Leave a Reply
Recent Comments
A thoughtful insight and ideas I will use on my blog. You’ve obviously spent some time on this. Congratulations
How come you do not have your website viewable in mobile format? cant see anything in my Droid.
I’d like to be able to write like this, but taking the time and developing articles is hard…. Takes a lot of effort.
This is definitely a wonderful webpage, thanks a lot..
It’s time for communities to rally.
Nice piece of info! May I reference part of this on my blog if I post a backlink to this webpage? Thx.
I’m impressed, I need to say. Really rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both educational and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head.
I just sent this post to a bunch of my friends as I agree with most of what you’re saying here and the way you’ve presented it is awesome.
Great blog here! Also your site loads up very fast! What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol
Nice post.Very useful info specifically the last part 🙂 Thank you and good luck.
I think I might disagree with some of your analysis. Are the figures solid?
Are the issues really as complex as they seem?
Nevertheless, it’s all carried out with tongues rooted solidly in cheeks, and everybody has got nothing but absolutely love for their friendly neighborhood scapegoat. In reality, he is not merely a pushover. He is simply that extraordinary breed of person solid enough to take all that good natured ribbing for what it really is.
it is a really nice point of view. I usually meet people who rather say what they suppose others want to hear. Good and well written! I will come back to your site for sure!
I believe this web site has some really wonderful info for everyone : D.
Great post. Just a heads up – I am running Ubuntu with the beta of Firefox and the navigation of your blog is kind of broken for me.
Thanks for discussing the issues and covering them in a well written format.
OK, you outline what is a big issue. But, can’t we develop more answers in the private sector?
I believe you have remarked on some very interesting points , thankyou for the post.
I would really like to appreciate the endeavors you cash in on written this article. I’m going for the similar best product from you finding out in the foreseeable future as well. Actually your creative writing abilities has urged me to begin my very own blog now. Genuinely the blogging is distributing its wings rapidly. Your write down is often a fine illustration showing it.