A cautionary tale from divided Belgium
TheStar.com – comment – A cautionary tale from divided Belgium
September 19, 2007
Three years ago, when he was still leader of the opposition, Stephen Harper singled out bilingual, bicultural Belgium as a fine example of successful federalism.
Today it’s more than a little embarrassing that just as he is to announce a key component of his renewed federalism – formally restricting Ottawa’s spending to federal jurisdictions – the Belgian model shows signs of being about to fission after 176 years of existence.
That country’s French-speaking Walloons in the south and Dutch-speaking Flemish in the north lead quite separate lives. They know, and apparently care, little about one another. For the past three months, with voters split along linguistic lines, Belgium has been unable to form a new government. More than 40 per cent of Flemish voters favour independence.
That sounds at first a little like Canada: a country split along linguistic lines, with nothing in common but a mutual antagonism.
But it isn’t really so. Canadians have stronger central institutions, for one thing. Belgium, with 10.5 million people, has 11 parties in parliament. It has two distinct party systems and two electoral colleges, one French-speaking, the other Dutch.
There are another five parliaments set up by language and geography. Power is so devolved that the country essentially operates as a city state, Brussels, surrounded by independent fiefdoms.
The Belgian case serves as a warning note to all who call themselves federalists.
Inter-penetration of language groups is substantial in Canada, but needs to be encouraged, which means official-language minorities need defending. Parliament needs parties represented in every region. Public and private bilingualism is an asset, to be encouraged in every part of the country. And Canadians could profit from incentives – student exchange programs, perhaps even holiday tax breaks – to get to know their neighbours in other regions.
As for the Harper government’s desire to clarify the separate roles of the federal and provincial governments, he should beware mollifying the Quebec political class at the expense of retaining genuine national scope for Ottawa.
A country has to be careful not to devolve itself to death.
______________________________________________________________
This is an edited version of an editorial yesterday in the Gazette, Montreal.
This entry was posted on Wednesday, September 19th, 2007 at 1:39 pm and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
7 Responses to “A cautionary tale from divided Belgium”
|
Leave a Reply
Recent Comments
Playing daily word games keeps your vocabulary sharp. Bot analysis explains why a guess was strong or weak. 49b838f0.
Very insightful commentary on treatment timelines and optimal therapeutic thresholds. Clear, concise, and academically sound review of the active mechanisms involved.
Offline reopening is possible once the local game files are fully stored. 6d4265c1.
Standing still too long lets the timer and the enemy waves catch up. bba12163.
Thank you for this detailed informational perspective. The breakdown of active pharmacokinetics and safety monitoring protocols provides a robust reference for healthcare research.
I found myself re-reading certain sections because they were so well explained. What stood out most was how every section flowed naturally into the next without feeling forced.
The practical takeaways in this article are what make it truly special, it is one thing to explain a concept well but this piece also shows readers exactly how to apply it.