Canadian shelters forced to turn away majority of women and children in need

Posted on April 28, 2016 in Child & Family Delivery System – News/National
Apr. 28, 2016.   Tavia Grant

On one typical day late last year, 416 women and children across Canada sought shelter to escape violence. Of that total, however, shelters were forced to turn away 73 per cent of those in need due to a lack of resources and capacity, an annual tally to be released Thursday shows.

The findings of the report demonstrate the degree of need across the country, where it says a “significant proportion” of shelters are chronically at overcapacity. The report, entitled Shelter Voices, also reveals the frequency with which women and children cross provincial borders to flee violence – nearly half, or 44 per cent, of shelters had received women from other provinces or territories in the past month alone.

“Clearly, fleeing abuse is a challenge that crosses borders,” the report said, adding that the issue of violence against women must be addressed at the national level, in addition to provincial efforts.

By the time a woman goes to a shelter, it’s often a last resort, said Lise Martin, executive director of the Canadian Network of Women’s Shelters and Transition Houses, which conducted the survey. “It’s rare that a woman will show up on the doorstep of a shelter where it’s a first incident or she hasn’t tried different alternatives.”

The shelter report cites Statistics Canada homicide data showing that a woman is killed by her current or former intimate partner an average of every six days in Canada. Death threats “are far more common,” the paper said. “Women seeking shelter from abuse are often doing so out of a very real sense of terror for the lives and safety of their children and themselves.”

Of the women at shelters on that typical day, 110 had been threatened with a gun. Pregnancy also raises the chances of extreme physical violence, the report noted. Shelters were aware of 148 pregnant women who were assisted on the snapshot day.

An internal Status of Women report last year noted that rates of violence against women have not diminished over time, and that gender-based violence remains “pervasive” in Canada. It found that aboriginal women and those in the North are particularly affected.

One mother of three children said in an interview that she sought shelter in Toronto last summer after fleeing abuse by her ex-husband. She relocated from Northern Ontario after prolonged verbal, emotional and physical abuse, as well as mishandling by local police – giving up her job and five-bedroom home to do so.

He was “attacking me through work, calling my boss … getting me in trouble at work, getting a hold of my bank accounts, going through Facebook, everywhere I turned he was trying to get at me. … I gave up my whole entire life, I sold everything, just to make the move here and start a new life,” she said.

“Coming to the shelter was the last resort. I’ve always been independent and managed to do things on my own. Having to be in a situation like this was very tough,” said the woman, who asked that her name be withheld to protect her safety and that of her children.

She said she wakes up at 5 a.m. to make lunches for her children and get them off to school, and worries that the instability is affecting them. One son has autism, so another challenge is finding special-needs child care for him. She is seeking affordable housing but doesn’t qualify for many options, and those available tend to require proof of a steady income.

“I feel so stuck. But through it all, I keep trying to be positive. That’s all I’ve got to do, because if I sit in my pity … nothing’s going to go right.”

This is the third national survey of shelters and transition houses serving women and their children who have been affected by domestic abuse. The numbers represent a one-day snapshot in November among 234 shelters from every province and territory in Canada. On a single day, those shelters housed 1,760 women and 1,915 children.

The count shows that four in 10 shelters had no available beds on that day and many shelters are grappling with complex needs, having become “the front lines for addressing trauma-induced mental-health concerns and coping mechanisms such as substance abuse.”

Need is urgent in the North – Nunavut, for example, where domestic violence rates are the highest in the country, has just five shelters, Ms. Martin noted. She also drew a connection between a lack of shelters in remote communities and a heightened risk that indigenous women could wind up missing or murdered.

Funding for many shelters has been stagnant or fallen in recent years. The recent federal budget allocated $89.9-million over two years toward the construction and renovation of shelters for victims of family violence. Another $10.4-million was promised for new shelters in First Nations communities, the majority of which lack shelters or safe houses.

Ms. Martin said she hasn’t seen details on how the money will be spent. She hopes to see sustainable funding over the long term, more equal access to services that protect women across Canada and a national action plan on violence against women – a move the United Nations recommends and countries such as Australia have already created.

“We need a national action plan that would ensure that women have access to comparable levels of services and protection across the country,” Ms. Martin said.

Back at the Toronto shelter, the woman who spoke with The Globe and Mail said she dreams of going to university and becoming a behavioural therapist, helping other families who are raising children with autism. She’s grateful for the services she is receiving and says access to the shelter has meant she can remain with her kids. For now, though, “it’s been really tough, raising the three of them in the shelter.”

< >

Tags: , , , , ,

This entry was posted on Thursday, April 28th, 2016 at 9:00 am and is filed under Child & Family Delivery System. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

One Response to “Canadian shelters forced to turn away majority of women and children in need”

  1. To the Editor,

    It is with little surprise and shock that I read the statistics in the “Shelter Voices” report. On a typical day, 416 women and children seek residency within a VAW shelter and of that total number 73 percent are turned away by shelters due to overcapacity and a lack of resources. Through-out my practicum at a VAW shelter, I have witnessed first-hand the effects of violence on families, and have encountered the number of barriers women face in a shelter on a day-to-day basis. I completely agree with your assessment that the overcapacity of shelters across Canada speaks to a failure on our government to ensure that all women across the country have equal access to levels of services and protection, especially women that belong to marginalized groups, or are geographically isolated. Through-out the article you have addressed statistics, however have failed to address the larger systemic barriers in place. Canada needs to develop a national action plan towards ending violence against women. This plan does not only need to focus on building and funding more shelters, which is an integral piece towards supporting women, but this plan also needs to look at addressing the multitude of barriers women face when fleeing abuse. Such barriers include: eligibility towards housing and funding programs, legal barriers, lack of mental health supports, lack of safe and affordable housing, food insecurity leading to larger demands on food banks, lack of resources and services in remote communities, loss of funding for educational programs, difficulties in pursuing legal actions, human trafficking, and so on. Yes, I agree with you that Canada is facing a shelter crisis and that there is a desperate need for resources within the shelter community. However, I do not believe a Band-Aid approach of simply using shelters as a mechanism to end abuse is the right solution. But rather, I believe we need to look at the complexities of violence against women, and create mechanisms that aid women before they must seek their last resort and call a shelter.


Leave a Reply