Canada urged to end ‘pension apartheid’
Posted on October 28, 2011 in Debates
Source: National Post — Authors: Jonathan Chevreau
NationalPost.com – FinancialPost/PersonalFinance
Oct 28, 2011. Jonathan Chevreau
Every Canadian needs $2-million in RRSP contribution room to achieve parity with public-sector defined benefit pension plans, the C.D. Howe Institute says.
As things stand, the system punishes those with defined-contribution pensions in the private sector and those who rely on what little RRSP room is granted them, says James Pierlot, principal with Toronto-based Pierlot Pension Law.
The $2-million figure comes from the value of public-sector DB plans for top managers earning $150,000 late in their careers. Rather than limit RRSP contributions to 18% of a prior year’s earned income, Mr. Pierlot would give every Canadian the lifetime RRSP contribution room, adjusted to inflation.
The need to redress the gap between pension “haves and have nots” has become urgent, Mr. Pierlot says. Indeed, a new book published by Wiley Canada – Pension Ponzi – makes the same point: It depicts a system of “pension apartheid” that favours 20% of workers with unionnegotiated public-sector DB plans at the expense of the rest who guarantee those pensions through their future taxes.
Most penalized are new Canadians, the self-employed, the chronically unemployed and those who have suffered market losses in RRSPs or prematurely withdrawn funds from them.
In an interview, Mr. Pierlot said his paper (titled Legal for Life) still calls for upfront tax deductions for RRSP contributions but no annual contribution limit. The only constraint would be coming up with the money. Plans would still be taxable once funds are withdrawn in retirement.
Eventually, registered retirement income funds (RRIFs) would decline to zero but would not be subjected to minimum annual withdrawal rules that may force seniors to sell at market bottoms.
An early draft advocated a “declining limit system.” So while the limit might fall from $2-million to $1.9-million the first year of a RRIF, and fall another $100,000 each year thereafter, someone with only $500,000 wouldn’t be forced to withdraw anything in the early years of a RRIF.
The paper does not discuss taxfree savings accounts, but Mr. Pierlot advocates a lifetime TFSA limit of $250,000 to $500,000. “The retirement system is intended for middleclass workers earning $50,000 to $150,000 a year,” he said, “Anyone earning less should not be in RRSPs but in TFSAs.”
His proposals were included in private-member’s bill C574, which passed first and second readings until the federal election intervened. The Retirement Income Bill of Rights was presented by Liberal pension critic Judy Sgro and supported by all parties except the Conservatives, Mr. Pierlot said.
“It said every Canadian shall have equal opportunity to accumulate pension income no matter how they are employed or where they were born. If it had passed, it would have forced changes to the Income Tax Act.”
Mr. Pierlot said he didn’t “cost” his ideas because Ottawa misrepresents RRSP and pension tax deductions as tax expenditures.
“They’re not,” he says. “Money goes into plans and accumulates tax-free but down the road, the government gets its tax with interest. Yes, it affects government cash flow in the short term, but it isn’t a tax-avoidance mechanism. It’s a tax deferral.”
Fred Vettese, chief actuary with Toronto-based Morneau Shepell, says Canadians “essentially have a lifetime limit already since unused RRSP contribution room can be carried forward indefinitely.” But it’s true average private-sector workers with RRSPs can’t replicate public-sector levels of retirement income. “If we truly felt public-sector plans provide an appropriate level of retirement income, the author is right in suggesting a $2-million lifetime limit to level the playing field.”
But there would still be inequity, Mr. Vettese said, because contribution rates needed to generate so much income would impoverish average RRSP savers over a working lifetime.
< http://business.financialpost.com/2011/10/28/canada-urged-to-end-pension-apartheid/ >
Tags: ideology, pensions, rights, standard of living, tax
This entry was posted on Friday, October 28th, 2011 at 10:51 am and is filed under Debates. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
269 Responses to “Canada urged to end ‘pension apartheid’”
« Older Comments | Newer Comments »
Recent Comments
You are a very smart person! 🙂
You have some helpful ideas! Maybe I should consider doing this by myself.
I wrote down your blog in my bookmark. I hope that it somehow did not fall and continues to be a great place for reading texts.
Αν έχεις ήδη αποφασίσει να φύγεις από τις πλατφόρμες με ελληνική άδεια ΕΕΕΠ, η ερώτηση δεν είναι «αξίζει;» αλλά «ποια από αυτές αξίζει περισσότερο;». Ελέγξαμε 15 διεθνείς στοιχηματικές εταιρείες που λειτουργούν στην Ελλάδα το 2026: ανοίξαμε λογαριασμούς με ελληνικά στοιχεία, δοκιμάσαμε καταθέσεις με κάρτα και κρυπτονόμισμα, και μετρήσαμε τον πραγματικό χρόνο ανάληψης. Το βασικό κίνητρο για τους περισσότερους είναι πρακτικό: οι διεθνείς πλατφόρμες δεν εφαρμόζουν αυτόματη παρακράτηση φόρου επί των κερδών, δεν κόβουν λογαριασμούς που κερδίζουν συστηματικά και προσφέρουν ευρύτερη γραμμή με περισσότερα αθλήματα. Οι εταιρείες που ακολουθούν δέχονται εγγραφή από την Ελλάδα, η πρόσβαση στον ιστότοπο δεν απαιτεί VPN και κανένας από αυτούς δεν βρίσκεται στον κατάλογο αποκλεισμένων τοποθεσιών της ΕΕΕΠ κατά την τελευταία επικαιροποίηση.
Aktualny przegląd promocji na 2026 rok obejmuje kasyna online, które oferują bonus bez depozytu w formie darmowych spinów, dodatkowych środków lub pakietu łączonego. Pokazujemy, jak aktywować ofertę, jakie wymagania obrotu trzeba spełnić oraz które limity wypłat warto sprawdzić przed rozpoczęciem gry. Bonus bez depozytu za utworzenie konta pozostaje jedną z najpopularniejszych promocji w kasynach online. Pozwala nowym użytkownikom przetestować platformę, dostępne gry kasynowe oraz obsługę konta bez konieczności dokonywania pierwszej wpłaty. Przygotowując ranking najlepszych kasyn z bonusami bez depozytu 2026, porównaliśmy aktualne propozycje operatorów, w tym oferty Roman Casino i NV Casino.
I really like your writing style, excellent info , thanks for putting up : D.
What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively useful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to contribute & help other users like its aided me. Great job.
Great blog here! Additionally your website rather a lot up very fast! What host are you the usage of? Can I get your associate link for your host? I desire my website loaded up as fast as yours lol
This blog post is excellent, probably because of how well the subject was developed. I like some of the comments too.
I cannot thank you more than enough for the blogposts on your website. I know you set a lot of time and energy into these and truly hope you know how deeply I appreciate it. I hope I’ll do a similar thing person sooner or later.
This is an awesome entry. Thank you very much for the supreme post provided! I was looking for this entry for a long time, but I wasn’t able to find a honest source.
If most people wrote about this subject with the eloquence that you just did, I’m sure people would do much more than just read, they act. Great stuff here. Please keep it up.
Surprisingly good post. I really found your primary webpage and additionally wanted to suggest that have essentially enjoyed searching your website blog posts. Whatever the case I’ll always be subscribing to your entire supply and I hope you jot down ever again soon!
Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all people you really recognize what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Kindly also seek advice from my web site =). We can have a link alternate contract between us!
Hello there, You have done an incredible job. I will certainly digg it and personally recommend to my friends. I am sure they will be benefited from this site.
I know this is not exactly on topic, but i have a blog using the blogengine platform as well and i’m having issues with my comments displaying. is there a setting i am forgetting? maybe you could help me out? thank you.
Are the issues really as complex as they seem?
very good post, i certainly love this web site, keep on it
Write more stories, more chapters.
Glad to be one of many visitants on this amazing site : D.